Thematic Review on Sustainability-Related Information in Remuneration Policies
Published 9 December 2022
Category: Impact and ESG
On 23 November 2022, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“DFSA”) published a thematic review on sustainability-related information in remuneration policies. The DFSA reviewed information given by six selected pension funds and life insurance companies.
According to SFDR article 5, financial market participants (“FMPs”) must include in their remuneration policies information on how the policies are consistent with the integration of “sustainability risks”, and this information shall be published on the website of the FMP. A “sustainability risk” covers an “environmental, social or governance event or condition that, if it occurs, could cause an actual or a potential material negative impact on the value of the investment”, cf. SFDR article 2(22). Therefore, it is a financial risk which a company and its investors as well as customers are exposed to. Sustainability risks differs from “sustainability impact” which covers situations where companies have an impact on environmental, social and governance issues (ESG).
Article 5 does not require FMPs to establish a connection between the FMP’s remuneration policy and its integration of sustainability risks. However, FMPs are required to disclose whether there is a connection, and if there is, to describe it.
The investigation showed that the majority of the surveyed companies had not provided adequate information. The DFSA found that the investigated FMPs often disclose whether the above-mentioned connection exist, but that information on how the connection is ensured is missing. Vague statements such as stating that the FMP considers sustainability risks in its remuneration policy is not adequate. Further, the DFSA found that several of the FMPs in their disclosures do not adequately distinguish between 1) how the remuneration policy seeks to contribute to the FMP’s sustainability objectives and 2) how it seeks to enhance the management of sustainability risks in the FMP’s investment process. Also, the DFSA underlined that in case of a connection between remuneration and integration of sustainability risks, it must clearly be described in the remuneration policy how the remuneration structure is contributing to ensuring non-excessive risk-taking regarding sustainability risks. Four of the investigated companies were on this basis given injunctions for insufficient information.
Based on the investigation, the DFSA has given the below recommendations, after which FMPs shall ensure:
- that the remuneration policy contains information on how the remuneration is in accordance with integration of sustainability risks, where sustainability risks are to be understood as financial risks, and that this information is published on the FMP’s website;
- that the remuneration policy describes, not only whether, but also how the remuneration policy is consistent with the FMP’s integration of sustainability risks. This entails that FMPs, which state that the remuneration policy is in accordance with the integration of sustainability risks, have to elaborate on how sustainability risks is considered as an element in variable remuneration schemes, etc.;
- that the FMPs comply with the information provided in their policy and that this can be proved.
- that the FMPs publish the relevant information required on a subsection to the FMP’s main website. It is not enough, that the information can be found only by using the search field.
- Consistency between the information provided on the website and the information provided in the remuneration policy.
The full report can be read here.
Tags: Sustainability
Also tagged ‘Sustainability’
Technical screening criteria for remaining environmental objectives now published
The Environmental Delegated Act introduces technical screening criteria for economic activities substantially contributing to one of the remaining four environmental objectives.
SustainabilitySimplification and requirement reduction are key words in 2024 Commission Work Programme
On 17 October 2023, the EU Commission adopted their 2024 Commission Work Programme focusing mainly on strengthening EU’s competitiveness through reduction of burdens on businesses and rationalisation of reporting requirements.
GovernanceSustainabilityIntroduction of EU Taxonomy Stakeholder Request Mechanism
On 17 October 2023, the EU Commission and the advisory body, Platform on Sustainable Finance, introduced the EU Taxonomy Stakeholder Request Mechanism.
SustainabilityStatus on the EU sustainable finance framework
In June 2023 the European Commission published and adopted a sustainable finance package with measures to expand and strengthen the EU sustainable finance framework. This update provides a closer overview of those measures which are now subject to scrutiny by the European Parliament and the Council.
Regulatory Technical StandardsSustainabilityProposal for Danish implementation of CSRD out for consultation
On 13 October 2023, the legislative proposal for implementation of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (“CSRD”) and a number of appertaining executive orders went out for consultation.
SustainabilityConsultations on the implementation of SFDR
On 14 September 2023, the European Commission initiated two consultations on the implementation of SFDR. The consultations focus on, among others, the regulation’s useability and role in combatting greenwashing.
Disclosure RequirementsRegulatory Technical StandardsSustainabilityStatus on the CSDD Directive
On 13 September 2023, the Danish Corporate Governance Board published their annual account for 2022-2023. The account contains a status on the CSDD Directive which is still negotiated in the EU.
SustainabilityMemo from the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority on periodic reporting
On 30 August 2023, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“DFSA”) published a memo describing the requirements in SFDR art. 11 for periodic reporting.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityNew reports on the understanding of greenwashing
The progress reports are a result of a push from stakeholders requesting greater market integrity, investor protection and trusted environments for sustainable investments as sustainability has become an important competitive factor.
ESMASustainabilityEuropean Sustainability Reporting Standards have been adopted
On 31 July 2023 the European Commission adopted European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) which are mandatory standards for companies under CSRD to use when reporting on sustainability information.
SustainabilityUpdated guide on the SFDR and Taxonomy Regulation
The updated guide takes regulation and guidance from public consultations and Q&A’s since July 2022 into account. Further, it reflects the most recent market practice on the application of the regulations.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityEU Commission answers questions on interpretation of SFDR
The EU Commission has published its answers to questions on the interpretation of SFDR. The questions were put forward by the ESAs in September 2022 in order to receive clarification within central aspects of SFDR.
Disclosure RequirementsSustainabilityEU Commission answers questions on interpretation of SFDR
The EU Commission has published its answers to questions on the interpretation of SFDR. The questions were put forward by the ESAs in September 2022 in order to receive clarification within central aspects of SFDR.
Disclosure RequirementsSustainabilityConsultation on the ESAs review of SFDR
The European Supervisory Authorities (EBA, EIOPA and ESMA) have earlier this month published a consultation paper in which they propose amendments to the Commission Delegated Regulation.
Disclosure RequirementsESMARegulatory Technical StandardsSustainabilityThematic review of sustainability disclosures for funds with sustainable investment as the objective
On 3 February 2023, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“DFSA”) published a thematic review of sustainability disclosures for eight funds with sustainable investments as their objective.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityPublic consultation on the update of the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises
In general, the Guidelines, last updated in 2011, are a set of non-binding recommendations to businesses for ensuring responsible business conduct in all areas where business interacts with society.
ComplianceGovernanceSustainabilityESMA consultation on the use of ESG or sustainability-related terms in fund names
On 20 February 2023, ESMA closed their consultation on Guidelines on funds' names using ESG or sustainability-related terms launched back in November 2022.
ComplianceESMASustainabilityOpinions issued on the draft European Sustainability Reporting Standards
The European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG) submitted a draft set of European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS Set 1) to the EU Commission in November 2022.
ComplianceESMASustainabilityNew development in Green Deal Industrial Plan
On 9 February 2023, a summit was held in the European Council in which, among other things, a green industrial plan and other measures to secure EU’s competitiveness going forward were discussed.
Cross-BorderGovernanceSustainabilityESG-related investing remains active
Fundraising for both new funds and startups in the ESG-related space seems insulated from the general decline in the market. Despite investors having seen a general market decline within VC investments (see also Startup whiplash hits some sectors harder than others) investing in ESG-related funds and startups continue.
SustainabilityEU unveils plan for future Net-Zero Industry Act and European Sovereignty Fund
Recently, the EU Commission presented a plan for a Net-Zero Industry Act and a European Sovereignty Fund as part of a bigger Green Deal Industrial Plan. The initiatives shall be seen in connection with the European Green Deal and the goal of making EU climate neutral by 2050.
Cross-BorderGovernanceSustainabilityRequirements for Gender Composition in Managements have Tightened
On 1 January 2023 new rules have imposed stricter requirements for targets and policies on the gender composition of managements. These rules cover both large Danish companies (covered by accounting class C), including state-owned and some listed companies (covered by accounting class D), as well as certain companies within the financial area
ComplianceDanish RegulationSustainabilityFinal Report on Minimum Safeguards
The European Commission expert group; Platform on Sustainable Finance, has published a final report on the minimum safeguards laid out in Article 3 and 18 of the Taxonomy Regulation. It replaces the draft report published in July 2022.
ComplianceSustainabilityFinal Adoption of the CSRD
The CSRD has now been finally adopted after the Council of the European Union on 28 November 2022 approved the European Parliament’s position. On 16 December 2022, the directive was published in the Official Journal. The date of entry into force is 20 days from the publication date.
ComplianceSustainabilityEU Legislation Takes Action Against Greenwashing
Lately, EU has sharpened its focus on preventing greenwashing as well as strengthening the sustainability reporting requirements. One step, among others, is the recent passing of the CSRD. Another is a proposal published in March 2022 by the European Commission with amendments for the Directive 2005/29/EC on Unfair Commercial Practices (UCPD) as well as the Directive 2011/83/EU on Consumer Rights.
Cross-BorderDanish RegulationSustainabilityA General Approach on the CSDD Directive Proposal Adopted by the Council
On 1 December 2022, the Council adopted its general approach on the proposal for a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence (CSDDD) which was adopted by the European Commission on 23 February 2022. This completes the negotiations in the Council.
SustainabilityCSRD has been Passed by the European Parliament
The European Parliament has passed the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (“CSRD”). CSRD replaces the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (“NFRD”), and introduces higher requirements of more detailed reporting, and a mandatory EU sustainability reporting standard.
ComplianceSustainabilityNew Recommendations from the Danish Council for Social Responsibility and Global Goals
The Council for Social Responsibility and Global Goals has presented 8 recommendations to the Danish government. The recommendations focus on how public authorities and companies can strengthen their transition to a circular economy and due diligence for sustainability.
SustainabilityInvest Europe ESG Reporting Guidelines: Setting the Industry Standard for ESG Reporting
Invest Europe has published a set of ESG reporting guidelines with the aim of providing user-friendly and advanced guidelines on sustainability reporting within the European private capital sector.
SustainabilityReview of SFDR Article 9 Funds by the Swedish FSA
The Swedish Finansinspektionen has reviewed 30 Swedish-registered UCITS- and special funds with sustainable investment as their goal (SFDR article 9 funds). Finansinspektionen analyzed how fund managers met the requirements for providing sustainability-related information to investors.
SustainabilityOther updates
Technical screening criteria for remaining environmental objectives now published
The Environmental Delegated Act introduces technical screening criteria for economic activities substantially contributing to one of the remaining four environmental objectives.
SustainabilityMiCA Guidelines on suitability assessments
On 20 October 2023, the European Banking Authority (EBA) and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) released a Consultation Paper outlining two sets of draft joint guidelines regarding suitability assessments concerning issuers of asset referenced tokens (ARTs) and crypto-asset service providers (CASPs).
Crypto-assetsESMAMiCAConsultations on MiCA Technical Standards
As previously mentioned on Mazanti Pulse, new legislation regarding the crypto-asset sector is on its way in the European Union.
Crypto-assetsESMAMiCARegulatory Technical StandardsSimplification and requirement reduction are key words in 2024 Commission Work Programme
On 17 October 2023, the EU Commission adopted their 2024 Commission Work Programme focusing mainly on strengthening EU’s competitiveness through reduction of burdens on businesses and rationalisation of reporting requirements.
GovernanceSustainabilityIntroduction of EU Taxonomy Stakeholder Request Mechanism
On 17 October 2023, the EU Commission and the advisory body, Platform on Sustainable Finance, introduced the EU Taxonomy Stakeholder Request Mechanism.
SustainabilityStatus on the EU sustainable finance framework
In June 2023 the European Commission published and adopted a sustainable finance package with measures to expand and strengthen the EU sustainable finance framework. This update provides a closer overview of those measures which are now subject to scrutiny by the European Parliament and the Council.
Regulatory Technical StandardsSustainability