Thematic review of sustainability disclosures for funds with sustainable investment as the objective
Published 8 March 2023
Category: Impact and ESG
On 3 February 2023, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“DFSA”) published a thematic review of sustainability disclosures for eight funds with sustainable investments as their objective. The review was focused on disclosures in key investor information documents (“KIID”) and prospectuses. Among others, the purpose was to investigate whether sustainability information was given in a comprehensive, clear, and adequate way as well as whether investors were given the required information.
The review investigated compliance with disclosure requirements following directly from the SFDR, Taxonomy and KIID Regulation. However, the DFSA has not reviewed the disclosures and templates required pursuant to the level 2 SFDR disclosure requirements applicable from 1 January 2023. Further, the review did not cover internal processes by the Alternative Investment Fund Managers (“AIFM”).
Overall, the DFSA found that the investigated AIFMs had not properly ensured that the disclosed sustainability information was sufficient. The disclosures were too generic on the sustainability issues. The DFSA underlined that for funds with sustainable investment as the objective it is especially important with adequate and comprehensive sustainability information since this information is essential for investors’ decisions.
The following observations made by the DFSA across the eight AIFMs and funds can be highlighted:
- Information on the sustainable investment objective has been inconsistent and unclear. As an example, in one of the funds DFSA found it difficult to assess whether the objective was solely reduction of carbon emissions or also a contribution to a circular and more resource-efficient economy. DFSA concluded that it is not problematic to have more than one objective, however, it must be clear what the fund’s actual objectives are.
- Information in the prospectuses on how the sustainable investment objectives of the funds are going to be attained and how the contribution to the objectives is measured have been insufficient or incomplete. In one of the investigated AIFMs, the fund had the objective of, among others, investing in accordance with the Paris Agreement and contributing to the achievement of the UN’s 17 Sustainable Development Goals (“SDGs”). However, since the prospectus did not include information on, among others, how it was ensured that the fund’s investments contributed to all 17 SDGs, DFSA found the information insufficient. DFSA hereby underlined that this information is central in context of the SFDR as investors need to be able to assess how their investments are impacted by the funds’ sustainable objectives. Further, this information is important for investors in order to be able to assess whether a trustworthy plan for the attainment and measurement of the investment objective has been made.
- When a fund commits to invest in environmentally sustainable economic activities in accordance with the Taxonomy Regulation, information on how the investments will meet the requirements for those economic activities have been either insufficient or not included. Among others, AIFMs need to ensure that for each fund it is informed how requirements for environmentally sustainable economic activities as well as the threshold values are complied with. Also, the prospectuses have been unclear and not consistent when it comes to information on the funds’ sustainable investment objectives. Further, it was underlined in the review of one of the AIFM, that the proportion of a funds’ underlying investments in economic activities that qualify as environmentally sustainable must be informed in percentage. Also, the prospectus must include information on the percentage proportion of investments in enabling and transitional activities.
- For several funds, the prospectuses did not include sufficient information on how it was ensured that the investments did not significantly harm environmental or social objectives as well as whether the underlying investments were made only in companies following good governance practices. They are both requirements for an investment to be sustainable. Specifically for the information on the do no significant harm-assessment, DFSA has attributed the deficiencies to the fact that AIFMs did not provide sufficient information on their criteria and processes for the assessment.
- KIIDs in several of the funds did not describe the sustainable investment objectives which the funds’ investments shall contribute to. Also, for some funds the DFSA found discrepancy between the KIID and the prospectus when it came to information on the objectives.
- Information on the impact of sustainability risks on the return of the fund as well as information on how sustainability risks are integrated into the investment decisions have not been addressed correct by several funds. They have described positive impacts of sustainability risks and included information on the funds’ own work regarding sustainability and the impact on the fund’s return. Both approaches are not in accordance with the actual definition of sustainability risks in SFDR art. 2(22). Also, DFSA underlined the importance of information on whether these risks have a low, medium, or high likely impact on the return of the fund. Further, DFSA has for one AIFM highlighted that the prospectus did not include information on the specific sustainability factors which form basis of the assessment on the impact of sustainability risks on the return of the fund. DFSA underlined the importance of these information as investors shall be able to understand the fund’s exposure to sustainability risks.
- Where an index has been used as a reference benchmark, information on how the index is adapted to the objective as well as how and why the index differs from a broad market index, has in some cases been left out of the prospectus. It is not enough only to state in the prospectus that an index has been used, which was the case for one of the investigated AIFMs.
DFSA has issued orders to each investigated AIFM based on of the above observations showing violation of disclosure requirements as well as material issues.
The press release and the individual statements can be found here.
Next steps: Later this year, the DFSA will follow their review up by publishing a memorandum in which they describe and elaborate on what they have identified as good practices within the area.
Also tagged ‘Compliance’
Thematic review of pension funds subject to SFDR article 8
The Danish Financial Supervisory Authority initiated an inspection of three pension funds’ disclosing pursuant to SFDR article 8 in November 2023.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityMemo from the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority on periodic reporting
On 30 August 2023, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“DFSA”) published a memo describing the requirements in SFDR art. 11 for periodic reporting.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityUpdated guide on the SFDR and Taxonomy Regulation
The updated guide takes regulation and guidance from public consultations and Q&A’s since July 2022 into account. Further, it reflects the most recent market practice on the application of the regulations.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityPublic consultation on the update of the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises
In general, the Guidelines, last updated in 2011, are a set of non-binding recommendations to businesses for ensuring responsible business conduct in all areas where business interacts with society.
ComplianceGovernanceSustainabilityESMA consultation on the use of ESG or sustainability-related terms in fund names
On 20 February 2023, ESMA closed their consultation on Guidelines on funds' names using ESG or sustainability-related terms launched back in November 2022.
ComplianceESMASustainabilityOpinions issued on the draft European Sustainability Reporting Standards
The European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG) submitted a draft set of European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS Set 1) to the EU Commission in November 2022.
ComplianceCSRDESMAESRSSustainabilityRequirements for Gender Composition in Managements have Tightened
On 1 January 2023 new rules have imposed stricter requirements for targets and policies on the gender composition of managements. These rules cover both large Danish companies (covered by accounting class C), including state-owned and some listed companies (covered by accounting class D), as well as certain companies within the financial area
ComplianceDanish RegulationSustainabilityFinal Report on Minimum Safeguards
The European Commission expert group; Platform on Sustainable Finance, has published a final report on the minimum safeguards laid out in Article 3 and 18 of the Taxonomy Regulation. It replaces the draft report published in July 2022.
ComplianceCSDDDCSRDSustainabilityFinal Adoption of the CSRD
The CSRD has now been finally adopted after the Council of the European Union on 28 November 2022 approved the European Parliament’s position. On 16 December 2022, the directive was published in the Official Journal. The date of entry into force is 20 days from the publication date.
ComplianceCSRDSustainabilityCSRD has been Passed by the European Parliament
The European Parliament has passed the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (“CSRD”). CSRD replaces the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (“NFRD”), and introduces higher requirements of more detailed reporting, and a mandatory EU sustainability reporting standard.
ComplianceCSRDSustainabilityNew Guide on SFDR and EU Taxonomy Regulation
Invest Europe has published a comprehensive members guide on EU ESG reporting requirements for fund managers to clarify grey areas that exist around the day-to-day application of the regulation.
ComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityAuthorised AIFMs’ Integration of Sustainability Factors and Risks Applies from 1 August 2022
Authorized AIFMs shall from 1 August 2022 ensure that their systems, processes, and internal controls reflect relevant sustainability risks as defined in the SFDR.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityFinal Regulatory Technical Standards for SFDR and Taxonomy Regulation are Published
The RTS will define the new standard for sustainability-related disclosures in the financial services sector in the EU and supplements provisions of the SFDR and of the Taxonomy Regulation.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityInvest Europe to set ESG Reporting Standards
In November 2021, Invest Europe released its Climate Ambition in which the association committed to contribute to the EU becoming climate-neutral by 2050 and pledged to help the P/E and VC industry move towards net zero.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityThe Danish FSA: Significant Room for Improvement for SFDR Disclosures
The Danish FSA has assessed the quality of 4 pension companies and eight credit institutions' website disclosures with regards to information about their policies on the integration of sustainability risks in the investment decision-making process.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityApplication of SFDR Level 2 Obligations Delayed (Again)
The European Commission has once again delayed the application of the level 2 obligations of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) until January 2023.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityCommission Delays Application Date for the ESG Disclosure and Taxonomy Regulations
The Commission has postponed the date of application of the detailed regulatory technical standards (RTS) under the ESG Disclosure Regulation and the Taxonomy Regulation by six months from 1 January 2022 to 1 July 2022.
ComplianceCross-BorderDanish RegulationCommission Clarifies Questions of Interpretation Regarding ESG Disclosures
The Commission has answered a number of questions from the European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) regarding the ESG Disclosure Regulation.
ComplianceCross-BorderDanish RegulationNew Danish Act on Screening of Foreign Direct Investments
The new act on control of foreign direct investments (the “Act”) was adopted on 4th May 2021. The Act introduces a new framework for government screening of foreign investments and certain types of agreements with Danish companies.
ComplianceCross-BorderDanish RegulationESA Publishes Joint Supervisory Statement on the Interpretation on Fund Managers’ ESG Disclosure Obligations
From 10 March 2021, fund managers are required to make certain ESG disclosures available on their website and in their pre-contractual disclosures to investors.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityDeferral of Certain DAC6-Related Time Limits
On 29 June 2020, the Danish minister of taxation issued an executive order which defers certain DAC6-related time limits.
ComplianceDAC6ESA Consults on Fund Managers’ ESG Disclosure Obligations
The European Supervisory Authorities (ESA) has published draft technical standards setting out detailed rules on i.a. fund managers’ obligations under the ESG Disclosure Regulation.
AIFMDComplianceDisclosure RequirementsSustainabilityCommission Proposes Deferral of Certain DAC6-Related Time Limits
Due to the COVID-19 crisis, the European Commission has put forward a proposal for a directive that will defer certain time limits of DAC6, the EU directive regarding mandatory reporting in relation to arrangements with cross-border implications.
ComplianceDAC6Call to Defer DAC6 Reporting
A group of financial associations, including Invest Europe, has requested a deferral of the DAC6 reporting obligation until 2021 across all member states and the UK.
ComplianceDAC6Proposal to Transpose DAC6 into Danish Law Presented in the Danish Parliament
On 6 November 2019 the Danish government presented its proposal to transpose the EU directive regarding mandatory reporting in relation to arrangements with cross-border implications (“DAC6”) into Danish law.
ComplianceDAC6Disclosure RequirementsProposal to Increase Certain Requirements for Managers under the AIFM and AML Act Published for Consultation
On 28 August 2019 the Danish FSA (in Danish: Finanstilsynet) published for consultation a draft proposal to change, among others, the Danish AIFM Act and the Danish AML Act.
ComplianceDanish RegulationKYC / AMLWhistleblowingJapan Deemed a Sector Specific, Safe Third Country by the Danish DPA
Transfer of personal data from Denmark to (private) organisations in Japan that are subject to the APPI will not require prior approval from the DPA.
ComplianceDanish RegulationGDPRDanish Company Faces Prosecution and a Fine of DKK 1.5 mill. for GDPR Violation
On 11 June 2019, the Danish Data Protection Agency ("DPA") has reported a Danish furniture company to the Danish police for not deleting information on approx. 385,000 customers.
ComplianceDanish RegulationGDPROther updates
Repeal of rules regarding shareholder loans and other amendments to the Danish Companies Act
On 19 December 2024, the Danish Parliament has adopted the amendment acts L71 and L72 regarding amendments to the Danish Companies Act and other Danish laws.
Venture CapitalAbolition of the ‘entrepreneur tax’ and other changes to Danish tax legislation adopted
On 19 December 2024, amendments to the Danish Corporation Tax Act, the Danish Capital Gains Tax Act and the Danish Personal Tax Act, as well as other Danish tax laws, were adopted by the Danish Parliament.
Venture CapitalThe Danish Financial Supervisory Authority publishes guiding statement on alternative investment fund managers’ inclusion of leverage in unlisted companies and issuers
On 17 December 2024, the Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (Danish FSA) published a guiding statement regarding the inclusion of leverage by alternative investment fund managers (AIFMs) in unlisted companies and issuers.
AIFMDDanish RegulationESMAThe Danish FSAThe Danish FSA’s role in the sustainability reporting in 2025
The Danish Financial Supervisory Authority (“FSA”) has published a short press release regarding their role in relation to the sustainability reporting in 2025.
CSRDProposal on independent providers of audit services regarding sustainability reporting
The Danish Parliament has presented a proposal for legislation on independent providers of audit services regarding sustainability reporting.
CSRDInvest Europe launches enhanced ESG reporting template
Invest Europe has launched an enhanced ESG reporting template to drive convergence and support early-stage investors developed with Venture ESG.
CSRDSFDR